|Holistic Health Magazine & Resource Directory
|Home Advertise Contact Us
|Health Articles | Interviews | Product Reviews | Bookstore | Holistic Directory
Taking Control of Our Food Choices
Interview with David Kessler, MD
Kessler, MD served as commissioner of the US Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) under George Bush Sr. and Bill Clinton. He is a
pediatrician and has been dean of the medical schools at Yale and the
University of California, San Francisco. He lives in Northern
California with his family.
The Share Guide: Dr.
Kessler, how has the average American's weight changed in the U.S. over
the last 20 or 30 years?
The Share Guide: Isn't this also
happening in the other nations in the world that adopt our modern
David Kessler: Exactly. In many cases, the preparation of the dish begins in the factory, where the meat is processed, battered, fried and frozen. Like many processed meats, chicken can contain as much as 19% of a water/sugar based solution, and salt is added as well. More salt and other spices are added before the battered chicken is prebrowned in oil and frozen. At the restaurants, the meat is deep-fried in oil again before it's served.
The Share Guide: Many people feel that they're at fault when they're overweight, thinking it's just poor willpower. But you make it clear in your book that it's actually due to the food industry stacking the deck against us.
David Kessler: We now have the science to show that a person who has a hard time controlling their eating--who's thinking about food all the time and who has a hard time stopping eating--their brain is being excessively activated. When we study people who have certain symptoms--loss of control in the face of high-calorie foods, lack of feeling full, this preoccupation with food--we call this conditioned hyper-eating. The first phase is anticipation. You're not even given the food yet, but just the thought, the smell, the sight of it--you see excessive activation in the reward pathways of the brain in the amygdala area. Then when they eat the food, that activation continues. The brain pathways stay activated until all the food is gone. So we now know it's not a question of willpower. In fact, the brains of millions of Americans are literally being hijacked by fat, sugar, and salt!
The Share Guide: Don't they actually use exhaust fans to pump the food smells out into the air at the fast food places?
David Kessler: Yes, because scent is a cue; it certainly stimulates you. I landed in San Francisco airport, and I started thinking about Chinese dumplings, even as the plane landed on the taxiway. Why? Because there was a place I had been at the food court that had these dumplings that I love. We're very effective learners. So we need to understand how the cycle of consumption works: we get cued; our brains get activated; we get aroused; our attention gets focused; our attention gets locked in; we consume. It's a momentary pleasure, but it's ephemeral. We get cued again every time we reach for and eat foods. It's going straight into the neural circuits. We'll do it again and again.
The Share Guide: One phrase in your book really made an impression: you refer to certain foods as "fat bombs."
David Kessler: Fat bomb was an expression used by someone in the food industry who designs foods. Chicken tenders are so loaded with batter and fat that my source in the food industry jokes that they're UFOs--unidentified fried objects. But I'm not the food curate. You want to eat a hamburger, I'm not going to object. It's when that 500 calories turns into a whole day's worth of calories, that's where the problem is. One of the signature hamburgers at Hardee's is called the Monster Thickburger, which famously contains 1,420 calories and 108 grams of fat. It's little more than fat on fat on salt on fat on salt on fat, all on a refined carbohydrate bun.
The Share Guide: Isn't one of the biggest problems that we're just eating too much at once?
David Kessler: Certainly. Researchers compared serving sizes at restaurants in Paris and Philadelphia and found that American portions averaged 25% larger. That held true both in chain restaurants, bistros, Chinese restaurants, and ice cream parlors. When I was trying to lose weight, I went to a food coach. She asked me what I ate. I told her I thought I had a relatively healthy diet. I told her what I ate, and she said, "Did you know you ate the equivalent of two meals in that one dinner?" Here I was, a physician, and I regulated foods at the Food and Drug Administration. She said, "You ate 12 ounces of protein in that meal." I didn't even really know what 12 ounces of protein looked like. I now eat half as much as I used to eat.
The Share Guide: So even though you're a medical professional, you still got caught off guard.
David Kessler: Exactly! The business plan of the modern American food company is to put their product on every corner, make it emotionally irresistible, make it entertaining, and make it socially acceptable to eat at any time. In fact, it's a food carnival. Who wouldn't want to get on the ride? We published this article called "Deconstructing the Vanilla Milkshake." What do you think it is in the vanilla milkshake that drives consumption? Sugar is the main driver, but when you study it closely, it's not any one ingredient. If I give you a package of sugar and say, "Go have a good time," you're going to look at me like I'm crazy. But add fat to that sugar, add texture, add temperature, add color, add mouth appeal. Then add the emotional gloss of advertising. Then add the social factor--you can do it with your friends, blow off steam, reduce stress. The food industry will say, "We're just giving the consumers what they want." But what do we end up with? A great public health epidemic.
The Share Guide: So we're becoming conditioned to overeat?
David Kessler: Yes. We now know that the food industry is excessively activating the brains of millions of Americans. Because food involves not only the learning circuits of the brain, but the motivational, habit, and memory circuits of the brain, food has become multisensory--and it's the multisensory nature of the stimulus that is driving intake.
The Share Guide: About the time Americans started gaining lots of weight, in the 1980's, is also the time when high fructose corn syrup became prevalent. Several nutritional experts that we've interviewed have pointed to this one ingredient as a big source of problems.
David Kessler: I think there's no doubt, whether it's sugar or high fructose corn syrup--both will stimulate intake, and both contribute significantly to overeating. I think the major culprits are fat, sugar, and salt--and especially highly processed foods. It's as if our food is predigested for us. In many instances, we're just eating adult baby food!
The Share Guide: Now that the economy is hurting, and people are more stressed than ever, it seems like eating can be a cheap form of indulgence, and allow people to feel rewarded.
David Kessler: That's true. We now understand that it's a form of self-medication. We need to understand the cycle. Eating for reward is eating for stimulation. It involves this arousal and release. We're constantly chasing something that doesn't exist. There's no doubt that consumption can give you momentary satisfaction, but in return for that, you're in this constant cycle that you can't escape from. So it's a figment of your imagination that the food you're eating is really comfort food. It's not! You're engaged in a cycle that you'll never, ever escape. Until you decide that you want to eat something else--by which I mean eat foods that are not loaded and layered with fat, sugar, and salt.
The Share Guide: Sounds like we need to watch out for our children.
David Kessler: Yes. The greatest gift you can give somebody, especially a child, is to prevent the neurocircuitry in the brain that is excessively responsive to fat, sugar, and salt from ever being laid down. It's much easier to prevent it, because once that neurocircuitry is laid down it's there for a lifetime.
The Share Guide: I was raised on bologna sandwiches, but I retrained my taste buds for brown rice and tofu.
David Kessler: How to do that is the thing millions of Americans want to know. They need to know that it can happen, because it can. But it involves new learning and new habits, which involves finding new things that you want more than food. People need to change the way they perceive food. Instead of looking at food and saying, "Boy, that cookie is my friend," now you look at it and say, "No, that's not what I want." People need to know they can add new learning--but it's not the stuff of fad diets or of miracle fixes.
The Share Guide: In your book you talk about how many chain restaurants are making food that's designed to go down very fast and easy.
David Kessler: Yes, it's almost as if it's predigested. It goes down in a whoosh, because the food is so highly processed. We used to chew about 20 chews per bite. Today, it's two or three. Food is now designed for a quick disappearance; the food industry understands that rollercoaster in the mouth. When that food goes down easy, you reach for the repeat.
The Share Guide: We recently saw the new film "Food, Inc" which brings to light the negative consequences of the industrialization of our food supply. We feed cattle and chickens corn to make them fatter than is natural. Then we pump them up with growth hormones and antibiotics. It changes the nutritional profile of the meat we're eating. How much do you think this is a factor in America's poor nutrition and obesity problem?
David Kessler: I think it's increasingly a problem, and we're going to see a movement back to real food. None of us wants to be fat. None of us wants the inevitable health consequences.
The Share Guide: You mention in your book that food companies have figured out how to fool consumers by being sneaky with the ingredient list. Sometimes instead of one type of sugar, they'll use several, so that they're not as high on the ingredient list.
David Kessler: The fact is our food is so bloated with fat, sugar, and salt it's hard to decipher how much has been added. We made food so chemically processed that it has none of the substance that helps slow down our eating. We need greater disclosure, there's no question--not only for processed food, but for foods we're eating in restaurants and fast food outlets. And it's very hard to find out. I went dumpster diving. That was the only way I could find out what was in the restaurant food. The food industry designs food for the bliss point. They construct foods these days for optimal stimulation and pleasure, and that is literally changing the brains of millions of Americans.
The Share Guide: You talk about awareness being the first step in breaking conditioned hyper-eating. Isn't that the first thing they tell alcoholics also: become aware of what you're doing?
David Kessler: Well, there's no question that awareness is the first step. But once you understand that your brain is being activated, how do you cool off the stimulus? That's the great challenge. The second step is to develop private rules for yourself. I know if I start eating french fries, I'm going to finish all of them. I just know that. So it's easier for me to just have a rule not to eat them. But the rule has to be unambiguous. It can't be "I'd really like those, but I'll deny myself today." That kind of rule won't work, because that only increases anxiety. A rule needs to be a rule you can believe in, and you want to follow. Another important thing is to create a plan: know what you're going to eat, when you're going to eat it, and eat with a certain structure, so you're not grabbing food constantly throughout the day. Structure is probably one of the greatest ways to create boundaries around your eating.
The Share Guide: You've written that when the brain knows that the reward will not be forthcoming, it shifts its attention elsewhere. So does that mean if you have a clear rule that you don't eat any fast food, then you'll be less tempted when you drive by?
David Kessler: Yes. If you tell a smoker "You can't smoke on the plane," they cue their brains and they have less cravings. They resign themselves. So if you've set certain rules that you always follow, that helps cool down the stimulus. If you want to lose weight, it's going to require a commitment to change your eating patterns and habits for the duration. That's not news that people want, because it's not the quick fix, it's not the miracle, but that's the only sustainable way to lose weight.
The Share Guide: You talk about the problem of snacking contributing to weight gain. But many nutrition experts have said that small meals more frequently are better than three big ones.
David Kessler: Structure is the best solution. And that could be three times a day, five times a day, whatever works for you. But eat in a planned way, not in a chaotic way. Snacking constantly is just responding to the cues in your environment. Every time you get a cue, your brain gets activated, and you reach for the food. That kind of eating needs to be replaced with structure. And it's very important not to feel deprived or hungry. So whatever you need to sustain you, do it. If you need to eat every three hours, that's fine. If you need to eat every five hours, that's fine. What's important is you anticipate when you're going to get hungry, and not allow yourself to feel excessively deprived. Because that's only going to increase the reward value of food and make it harder to stop.
The Share Guide: Some people have trouble recognizing that they are full, and so they eat too much. What causes this?
David Kessler: What's going on is the brain is being stimulated and the reward pathways are being activated. So the peripheral mechanisms that allow you to sense fullness don't even get through to your brain.
The Share Guide: So are you saying the combination of sugar on fat on salt suppresses the feeling of satiety?
David Kessler: Yes, because your brain is being so highly activated, that's preoccupying your working memory, and you're not sensing the other peripheral sensations of fullness. The neurocircuits of your brain are being activated and they are hijacking the body's regulatory mechanism.
The Share Guide: What are some of the best ways to break the cue/urge/reward habit cycle?
David Kessler: That's the key question. You can get rid of the cues in your home and create a safer environment, but then when you walk down the street, you're still going to get bombarded. Eating in a planned and structured way is very important. Developing private rules for yourself, as I mentioned before, also helps. In the end, the most important thing is to change how you perceive food. If you look at the food and say, "Look how they're loading and layering it with fat, sugar, and salt; that's not my friend."
The Share Guide: So changing our emotional appraisal of food, is that what you meant by counter-conditioning?
David Kessler: Right. It's changing how you value that stimulus. If you look at that piece of chocolate cake and say, "That's going to make me feel better," then you're only going to want it more. You have to realize that it may make you feel better for an instant, but it throws you into this cycle that you're forever chasing. And next time you get cued, you're only going to want it more. In essence, you are searching for something from food for a degree of satisfaction that will never exist.
The Share Guide: What is the power of priming? And how do we circumvent this?
David Kessler: Sometimes just one taste of a food, a single bite, is enough to trigger conditioned hypereating. Priming involves stimulating areas of your brain, and then it's hard to shut those areas off--and you will stay activated and continue to eat until all the food is gone. That's what the food industry knows when it tells us "Bet you can't eat just one." But priming only holds power for a short time. If you eat one piece of candy and there's a bowl of them in front of you, chances are you will keep eating more. But if no more are available or you have to search for them, the priming response may be undermined.
The Share Guide: You've written that lapses should be expected, and we shouldn't give up just because we've slipped.
David Kessler: That's right, it's only human--that old neurocircuitry, that old learning is going to show its head. That's part of being human. You have to understand that those things are going to happen occasionally, and you shouldn't beat yourself up for slipping. Just try again.
The Share Guide: When we interviewed Jack LaLanne years ago, he said, "Food is queen, but exercise is king." But it looks as though you see it the other way around.
David Kessler: Exercise is certainly key in maintaining weight loss. But if I gave you a candy bar, that's 300 to 400 calories, and you could eat that in two minutes. How long would it take you to work that off? Several multiples of that, so it's an unfair equation. Food has become so energy dense, you're fighting an uphill battle. If you expect to be able to keep on eating energy dense foods, you're never going to be able to work off the calories, because it's just so much harder and more time consuming to work off the calories than to eat the food.
The Share Guide: What do you mean when you talk about food being designed for hedonic value?
David Kessler: The food industry understands how to construct and develop food for optimal sensory stimulation and pleasure. Hedonics involves five factors: anticipation, visual appeal, aroma, taste and flavor, and texture and mouthfeel. We now know that this involves activating certain parts of the brain.
The Share Guide: This is done so restaurants can get what you call a "larger share of stomach?"
David Kessler: Yes, the food industry certainly understands that fat, sugar, and salt stimulate intake. They understand that people will come back for more. Maybe they don't understand the neuroscience, but I think there is no doubt that they construct foods for the maximal hedonic experience.
The Share Guide: At a recent trade show we heard a lecture where they said that 25% of the American population cares about healthy eating, 25% doesn't care at all, and that 50% are somewhere in the middle.
David Kessler: I think we've made nutrition increasingly confusing. It's very hard to see what is real food. And I think we need to move back to a simpler time, where we're focused on eating real foods--fruits and vegetables and whole grains. It sounds so simple, but it's hard to do, because our behavior has become so conditioned and driven by fat, sugar, and salt that's loaded and layered into our foods, and our brains are constantly being bombarded with food cues.
The Share Guide: In the future, do you think the food industry will be held accountable for caring more about profits than the health of the American public?
David Kessler: I think there's no question that the food industry needs to change. I think the government needs to do more disclosure and education. But I think in the end, just because our brains are being hijacked by all the food cues, doesn't mean we can't take steps to protect ourselves.
Jack LaLanne on exercise and healthy living
Jack LaLanne on nutrition and aging well
Mollie Katzen on wholesome food and nutrition
Dean Ornish, M.D. on low-fat diets and nutrition
Andrew Weil, M.D. on diet and nutrition
Sugar: Toxic Invader #1
Reversing Type 2 Diabetes & Insulin Resistance
The Health Risks of Visceral Obesity
The Skinny on Weight Loss Products
Holistic Health Directory
Bodywork and Massage
Business and Personal Services
Counseling and Therapy
Education, Schools, Classes
Natural Foods/ Healthy Products
Psychic Arts/Energy Medicine
Restaurants and Healthy Dining
Retreats, Spas, Travel
Tools for Living
Writing and Books
|© 1995-2013 The Share Guide → Home | Site Map | Healthy Products | Advertise | Directory